[gobolinux-users] LiveCD proposal: Use a windows folder to store information

Rafael Guterres Jeffman rafael at tteng.com.br
Thu Nov 23 11:52:09 UTC 2006

I once created a Linux image over NTFS, it does not work.

In fact it does work, but since NTFS do not have (or had) symlinks, 
several files were duplicated, as the directory hierarchy in GoboLinux 
is based on symlinks, it would be not feasible at all.

OTOH, there could be a way, by creating a big file on the NTFS 
filesystem which would be mounted as a loopback device. I also did this 
anh it works fine.

Although, I don't think there will be enough gain for GoboLinux to 
implement such feature that would demand a lot of efforts from the 
(still) small number of developers/maintainers.


Andy Feldman wrote:

>On 11/22/06, Martin Baldan <martinobal at gmail.com> wrote:
>>There's a linux distro (topologilinux) which does something similar, but I
>>think they use a virtual disk image, while I propose using real windows
>>subdirectories. What do you think?
>That's a really neat idea, and I'd love to see it happen, if it's
>feasible. Is there a particular reason you actually want the file
>structure to be in NTFS, rather than just using a single disk image? I
>don't think "being able to edit Gobo files from Windows" is a very
>useful feature, although I guess it might let you recover a busted
>install without using a LiveCD.
>There are some potential pitfalls with the individual file approach, though:
>- NTFS doesn't have UNIX permissions, so certain programs that check
>the permissions of files before executing (e.g. sudo) wouldn't work.
>You might have to run as superuser the whole time like on the LiveCD.
>- Would NTFS even support special file system objects like those in
>/S/K/D? I don't know how /dev works well enough to guess.
>- I can't find any Distros which do it the individual file way, so
>whoever impleneted it in Gobo would probably be breaking entirely new
>ground. For something that's not the main goal of Gobo, I don't know
>how much effort anyone would want to put into it. (Remember, Gobo is
>not exactly intended for Windows newbies to get a simple taste of
>Phat Linux can apparently boot straight from within Windows without
>needing to insert a CD, which would be better, but again it uses a
>disk image rather than using NTFS directly for its file system.
>Anyway, that's an interesting feature suggestion. If it was
>implemented, I would definitely burn some Gobo discs and get my
>friends to try it. The main thing stopping me now is that I don't want
>to mess up their system by partitioning... I've had bad luck with
>gobolinux-users mailing list
>gobolinux-users at lists.gobolinux.org
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: smime.p7s
Type: application/x-pkcs7-signature
Size: 3245 bytes
Desc: S/MIME Cryptographic Signature
Url : http://lists.gobolinux.org/pipermail/gobolinux-users/attachments/20061123/8ae75a88/attachment.bin 

More information about the gobolinux-users mailing list